“What is good for me, is not necessarily good for you!”
So often we hear such a statement, yet we rarely take a moment and reflect upon an affirmation that have so shaped our thinking and society.
At first, it may seem harmless; each person has a set of morals, beliefs, customs…etc and so it seems “logical” to say that what is good for one person, a family, a society, or a nation, is not necessarily good for another. After all, beliefs, customs, morals, mores are all relative! Or so we think or led to think.
If we reflect further we may ask: what if my customs or laws dictate that I shall murder every black- haired and green-eyed person? or perhaps every disabled person who’s health requirement cost his family, or the “system” more than $350/day? Or what if my beliefs allow me to eliminate or marginalize any person not producing a certain income? Now would we still think that what is good for me is not necessarily good for you? Furthermore, who is the “you” and who is the “me”?
Some may object at that line of thinking and argue that the statement above contain the key word “necessarily” as a guarantor against extreme cases. In other words, “necessarily” places limits. But where do we draw the limits? And who will draw such limits? Me? You? Society? The government? The Church? The Martians?
Who would determine what is good, and how do we find that good? In other words, who will “bound and loosen” (Mt 16:19, 18:18). The point I am making is that there are some universal objectively good acts and evil acts; there are acts that are good in and of themselves and acts that are evils in and of themselves. One cannot be left to make decision based on the whims of his conscience. That is unfortunately nothing less than differing to the caprices of ones character. After all, conscience is not infallible!
Some may further argue that we cannot remove the circumstances from the acts; you cannot sincerely think that killing in self-defense is the same as killing in a mass murdering fashion, such as Stalin or Hitler.
There are circumstances indeed, but these circumstances do not change the intrinsic nature (the evil nature) of the act of killing. The circumstances do not lessen the gravity of the inherent evil act of killing for example. I am sure that Stalin had “good” reasons for sending dissentient minds to the Gulag; he simply wanted the Siberian cold to refresh their ideas! Hitler, needed more grease for his tanks, and so found it perfectly acceptable to incinerate few human! No matter the reason or the circumstance, it can never be a criterion by which we measure the evil or goodness of an act. But understandably “keeping God’s Law in particular situations can be difficult, extremely difficult, but it is never impossible.” (VS §102)*
An act that is intrinsically good, is linked to Truth. Then what is truth you may ask? Yes, Pilate asked Jesus “what is truth?” (Jn18:8) such a question of the confused and perplexed man “who often no longer knows who he is, whence he comes and where he is going” (VS §84). What is Truth is a question for which an answer would go beyond these few lines, though it is perhaps a quest of the hungry souls. Souls that should find themselves naturally drawn toward the right path that is the Way, leading them to the One who is Truth, so as to ultimately attain the real Life. (Jn14:6). Let us then reflect!
*VS: John Paul II Encyclical: Veritatis Splendor (The Splendor of Truth) 1993
No comments:
Post a Comment